9 Best Earrings for Nickel Allergy | Various Designs, Styles and Materials

Itchy ears from your new earrings? You better check if they are nickel free! 

A nickel allergy can occur out of the blue, from a shopping weekend, a long night of partying or simply leaving your earrings on a little too long. These allergic reactions are sometimes difficult to treat and thus require you to stay away from nickel-based ear accessories. 

However, just because you’re allergic to nickel doesn’t mean you should avoid wearing earrings altogether. There are many alternatives like sterling silver and titanium earrings you can settle for as the best earrings for nickel allergy.

Learn more here!

Gold earring on a smiling woman

Reviewing the Best Earrings for Nickel Allergy

The following is a curated list of the best earring alternatives for nickel allergies that we reviewed:

  • Petite Diamond Huggie Hoop Earrings
  • London Blue Topaz Stud Earrings in 10K Yellow Gold
  • Princess-Cut Diamond Solitaire Stud Earrings in 14K Gold
  • Four-Prong Earrings
  • Hoop Earrings in 14K Yellow Gold
  • Composite Diamond Accent Double Frame Stud Earrings in Sterling Silver with 14K Gold Plate
  • Men’s 1/5 CT. T.W. Hexagon Multi-Diamond Layered Stud Earrings in Stainless Steel
  • Ball Stud Earrings 8mm 14K Yellow Gold
  • Ross-Simons Italian 18kt Yellow Gold Teardrop Earrings

1. Petite Diamond Huggie Hoop Earrings

This pair of hoop earrings are a fashionable accessory for your wardrobe and great earrings for everyday use no matter the occasion. They have a simple yet dainty Huggie earring design that fits perfectly with most ear lobe shapes due to their compact sizes.

Round pavé diamonds are aligned along the 14k yellow gold vermeil to give it that sparkle that comes with any gold jewelry. Alternatively, you can also choose other colors instead, like the 14k rose and white gold options sold with the same 30% discount as the original.

Petite Diamond Huggie Hoop Earrings

Features

  • 1/2 inch diameter to fit most earlobes comfortably
  • 14k yellow gold with alternative white and rose gold color options
  • Hinged snap back
  • Round brilliant-cut pavé diamonds for extra sparkle

Pros

  • Versatile for all occasions and dress codes
  • Available in multiple color options for better preference
  • Perfect earrings for sensitive ears 
  • Huggies earring design for comfortable fitting
  • High-quality 14k gold metal

Cons

  • The clasp isn’t very secure and can easily get stuck when taking off fabric such as sweaters while they’re still on.

Recommendation

The earrings are suitable for anyone looking for versatile accessories they can wear anywhere and in any attire.

2. Four-Prong Earrings

These earrings are some of the best hypoallergenic jewelry for anyone looking to make a fashion statement wherever they go. We were amazed by how these earrings sparkled despite their compact diamond size.

However, we can comfortably classify these as the best earrings because they have your preferred diamonds and broader metal options, including 14k and 18k gold. The product also includes platinum as a material option for anyone allergic to gold but still wants to maintain the same classy look with these diamonds. 

Four-Prong Earrings

Features

  • 14k Rose Gold for an exquisite matching look with any attire
  • Guardian or push backing clasp for maximum security
  • Round cut diamond shape for a classic jewelry setting
  • Total diamond carat weight of 0.60 Ct

Pros

  • It comes with four-pron earrings in 14k rose gold
  • You can set your choice of diamonds 
  • Each earring comes with an appraisal
  • Free returns in case of transport damages or dissatisfaction
  • Free shipping for the products to the buyer

Cons

  • The shipping and delivery time might be longer than expected or indicated.

Recommendation

The earrings are suitable for anyone interested in a range of diamond options on a specific brand and metals other than the typical gold earring in stocks. 

3. London Blue Topaz Stud Earrings in 10K Yellow Gold

There are many other gems other than diamond to energize your wardrobe, and this blue stone with a 10-karat yellow gold frame should be convincing enough. The round-shaped gemstone goes perfectly with that navy or yellow attire you’ve been dying to try out in your closet.

The stone is held in place using prongs to depict classical or traditional jewelry that’s a perfect give for her. At only about $100, these hypoallergenic earrings should bring out the best in you on that special night.

London Blue Topaz Stud Earrings in 10K Yellow Gold

Features

  • 10k yellow gold metal frame 
  • Round-shaped blue gemstone 
  • Friction-back earring back type for proper security
  • 5mm earring length and width

Pros

  • A natural blue gemstone that’s unique to diamond studs
  • It comes with a beautiful gift box for the perfect present
  • Secure earring back type that prevents loss during vigorous activities
  • Fits perfectly with brightly colored dress codes

Cons

  • The gemstone has a compact size that’s smaller than the metal frame.

Recommendation

We recommend this product to anyone looking for the perfect gift different from the typical diamond gemstone studs.

4. Princess-Cut Diamond Solitaire Stud Earrings in 14K Gold

Stud earrings are one of the most popular diamond accessories for men and women. These solitaire stud earrings feel as good on your ear as they look in person and are a good choice for anyone with allergic reactions to nickel. The default 1/5 carat stones shine radiantly even under low light, and you also have the option of choosing your preferred carat weight, which ranges from 3/8 to 1 1/2 carats. 

You can also choose your preferred stone shape between princess-cut and round options and select between 14k rose, white, and yellow gold color options for the best match.

1/5 CT. T.W. Princess-Cut Diamond Solitaire Stud Earrings in 14K Gold

Features

  • Diamond stone type for maximum sparkle 
  • Default white stone color that goes with every dress code
  • Stone carat range under 1/4
  • High-quality gold metal material
  • 14k gold karat with a polished finish

Pros

  • It comes with a lifetime diamond commitment plan for service and repairs
  • Available in multiple color options for versatile use
  • You can select your desired carat weight and stone shape
  • Free shipping available with no minimum purchases
  • Unisex nickel-free earrings for everyday use

Cons

  • It has a smaller compact size than the normal concave men’s diamond earrings.

Recommendation

We recommend these earrings to anyone looking for a stylish set of unisex studs with compact sizes that compliments their earlobe size.

5. Hoop Earrings in 14K Yellow Gold

You don’t always need gemstones on your earrings to make a bold statement or complete your attire because the simplicity of hoop earrings is more than enough. These hoop earrings have a classic but fashionable look that pair well with most of the outfits in your wardrobe and are suitable for all occasions.

They may look like your typical hoop ear accessories, but upon closer inspection, you’ll notice the chic textured finish that makes you confident enough to wear these earrings anywhere and everywhere. You can’t go wrong with the 14-karat yellow gold hoops on your sensitive ears, whether you’re preparing for an interview or dressing for a romantic evening.

Hoop Earrings in 14K Yellow Gold

Features

  • Yellow gold metal that pairs well with most colors
  • Hinge with notched post
  • 50mm earring length
  • 14k metal stamp

Pros

  • The item is eligible for a lifetime jewelry care plan 
  • Free shipping available
  • Simple yet elegant design with the textured finish
  • Suitable for all occasions

Cons

  • The earrings have a basic design until inspected at a closer angle, making them look simple even when they’re not.

Recommendation

These earrings are perfect for anyone with sensitive ears looking for a quality product that’s versatile for their schedule and fashion style. 

6. Composite Diamond Accent Double Frame Stud Earrings in Sterling Silver with 14K Gold Plate

Even though this is the cheapest pair of earrings on this list, the product design took our breath away with its antique-inspired style. This earrings set is an excellent option for people with nickel allergies looking for unique hypoallergenic jewelry that offers a similar sense of class and style to their wardrobe.

The metal is composed of sterling silver material coated with a 14k gold plate, giving it that golden appeal that matches most dress codes. Each stone includes a composite of round diamond accents under 1/4 carats that glows perfectly under the light. 

Composite Diamond Accent Double Frame Stud Earrings in Sterling Silver with 14K Gold Plate

Features

  • Good quality sterling silver frame material
  • Stone carat range of under 1/4 
  • Yellow metal color
  • Friction back for the best security
  • 14K Gold Plate coating for a pure gold finish

Pros

  • Unique vintage-inspired design that’s unique to most stud earrings
  • Sterling silver metal to prevent any allergic reaction to gold or nickel
  • Unisex earrings are versatile for most occasions and attire
  • It comes with a lifetime warranty plan for servicing and repairs
  • Free shipping without minimum purchases required

Cons

  • Compared to similar hypoallergenic earrings, the metal finishes wear off rapidly with frequent use. 

Recommendation

The studs are suitable for anyone searching for a bold and modern look that would bring out the best of their attire. 

7. Men’s 1/5 CT. T.W. Hexagon Multi-Diamond Layered Stud Earrings in Stainless Steel

Are you searching for a unique pair of men’s earrings that don’t conform to the standard round shape and basic specs of studs? This pair of hexagon multi-diamond layered stud earrings would be the best hypoallergenic earrings for you or your partner. The studs are crafted using surgical-grade stainless steel, perfect for men with sensitive skin. 

Each earring has a raised center with a hexagon-shaped diamond composite that shines brighter than most studs under the light. The diamonds are 1/5 ct giving them an authentic sparkle and secure comfortably on your ear using friction backs.

Men's 1/5 CT. T.W. Hexagon Multi-Diamond Layered Stud Earrings in Stainless Steel

Features

  • Made using white and polished stainless steel for that extra shine
  • Natural stone diamond of 1/5 carat that sparkles brightly 
  • Hexagon-shaped for a unique stud earring design
  • Free shipping without minimum purchases
  • Optional lifetime warranty plan for services and repairs

Pros

  • Unique hexagon design that makes it stand out from most men’s stud earrings
  • Stainless steel jewelry that’s a suitable alternative for men with sensitive ears
  • Friction backs for security and comfortability during movement
  • The multi-diamond stone design gives off a brighter sparkle than most single-diamond studs

Cons

  • The studs are only available in a single color and diamond shape, giving you limited preference options.

Recommendation

We’d recommend this product to any man looking to keep his attire fresh and modern wherever he may go because of the stud’s fashion versatility. 

8. Ball Stud Earrings 8mm 14K Yellow Gold

You’d have to be bold enough to find these ball stud earrings suitable for your wardrobe accessories. These earrings looked nothing less than fancy with their 14k yellow gold color and their unique brochette stud design.

The sparkling gold makes them stand out at any party, provided you’re wearing a matching costume that compliments them. Even though they lack a stone, these earrings showed us that you don’t need diamonds on your ear to sparkle when you are under the spotlight because they give off enough radiance to be noticed efficiently.

Ball Stud Earrings 8mm 14K Yellow Gold

Features

  • 14k yellow gold metal frame with shiny polish
  • Friction backs for maximum security during intensive activities like dancing
  • 8mm ball studs that stand out when reflected under light
  • Stone excluded from the design

Pros

  • It has a compact size with a great classic look
  • The 14k yellow gold color makes it a versatile accessory for every occasion.
  • The gold finishing still makes it sparkle despite lacking a precious stone
  • A lifetime warranty plan for servicing is offered

Cons

  • The studs don’t have any precious stones such as diamonds that could add aesthetic value. 

Recommendation

We recommend these earrings to anyone searching for a bold design that gives a classy stud vibe but without the diamond. 

9. Ross-Simons Italian 18kt Yellow Gold Teardrop Earrings

While you probably don’t consider buying authentic jewelry from third-party sources, you have to give these teardrop earrings by Amazon a chance. What impressed us most about these earrings is the Italian design that resembles an enlarged teardrop with the classy elegance of a unique accessory.

You can pair these earrings with your casual or formal dress codes, and they’re also a perfect gift for your loved one. The earrings aren’t solid, making them beautifully light and convenient to move around without strain.

Ross-Simons Italian 18kt Yellow Gold Teardrop Earrings

Features

  • Italian 18k yellow gold metal studs
  • Lever backings for maximum security during intense activities
  • Gold polish finish that offers an extra shine under light
  • 1 1/4 in. hanging length and 2.6 grams weight

Pros

  • The product was made in Italy with the finest Italian jewelry making it unique.
  • These studs can go perfectly with casual and formal attires
  • They’re the perfect give for anyone that prefers modern or traditional jewelry
  • A gift box is included that’s customized for any occasion or celebration
  • It is light enough to be worn even by kids

Cons

  • These are not solid earrings hence the lightweight material.

Recommendation

We’d recommend this pair of earrings to anyone searching for a gift for their loved one without information about what type of earrings they like because they fit both modern and classic designs. 

Choosing Nickel-Free Earrings for Sensitive Ears

Let’s look at some of the best nickel-free earrings made from different but safer materials. 

Medical Grade Plastic Earrings

These earrings are the best choice for people with sensitive skin and are often preferable for children. These earrings are made from materials used in hospitals for medical devices and implants, making them a better alternative for sensitive ears. 

Still, there’s a difference between plastic earrings and medical-grade ones forcing you to be cautious when buying. Plastic jewelry is bad for sensitive skin because it can cause infections, especially with freshly-pierced ear lobes. 

Titanium Earrings

Titanium earrings are considered extremely hypoallergenic because it’s harmless and used to make a broad range of medical devices and implants. The material has a dark silver color, and the earrings are very versatile. If you want to avoid risks associated with allergic reactions while still wearings your earrings to any occasion, choose titanium as your go-to material. 

Woman in a white dress wearing a pin as an earring

Stainless Steel Earrings

Stainless steel is an affordable hypoallergenic material option for earrings. Most stainless steel earrings are inexpensive and versatile when matching your outfits with accessories. However, this material isn’t the safest option because it also contains elements such as nickel in its alloy, though in extremely small quantities. 

Surgical Grade Stainless Steel

Surgical steel is a type of stainless steel, but stainless steel isn’t surgical steel. The earrings crafted using surgical stainless steel are made specifically for people with sensitive skin because it’s the same material used by doctors for their surgical tools. Surgical steel earrings are better resistant to corrosion than standard stainless steel ones and even cost more due to the material’s biomedical applications.

FAQs

What Earrings Are Best for Metal Allergy?

Your best options are titanium and medical-grade plastic earrings because they don’t contain any nickel and have little to no allergens in their alloys. 

What Earrings Can I Wear With a Nickel Allergy?

If you have a nickel allergy, you should avoid any nickel jewelry in its alloy. These include jewelry made from metals like stainless steel, titanium, 14k or 18k yellow gold, and sterling silver. 

What Makes Jewelry Hypoallergenic?

Hypoallergenic jewelry contains little to no irritating alloys and is made from metals like titanium, gold, stainless steel, palladium, and niobium. 

Man wiping a ring

What Metals Cause Allergic Reactions?

Many common metals in our everyday lives trigger allergic reactions. Nickel is one of the most typical allergens and accounts for most allergic reactions in jewelry. Other metals include:

  • Copper – Usually mixed with gold to create rose gold variation.
  • Brass – Made from combining copper and zinc.
  • Plated materials

How Do You Know if You Have Sensitive Skin?

Sensitive skin is more prone to stimuli after contact with allergens than normal skin. You must know the signs and symptoms of these allergies to determine whether or not your skin is sensitive. Some of these signs and symptoms include, but are not limited to:

  • Itchy skin
  • Redness
  • Swelling
  • Rashes and bumps
  • Dry patches

What Type of Earrings Are Nickel-Free?

When searching for hypoallergenic earrings, titanium and medical-grade plastic earrings are considered the best nickel-free options. Another option includes stainless steel, but this has significantly small nickel elements in its alloy. 

Are Stainless Steel Earrings Nickel-Free?

No. Most people believe that stainless steel is nickel-free, but most of its alloys contain small percentages of nickel. 

A Sparkle of Charm

Your earrings are an outlet to express yourself, and at Charm and Chain, we strive to provide you with the most beautiful pieces that give you a voice.