Is a Promise Ring an Engagement Ring? | What are the Differences?

Is a promise ring an engagement ring?

It seems that everyone has an opinion on what precise meanings the two rings carry, making it challenging to tell the difference. So, what’s the scoop?

Well, there’s no need to wonder any longer because we have your answer right here! We’ve got all the information you need on whether or not a promise ring means what you think it does.

We’ll also tell you why it’s absolutely important to know the difference between a promise ring and an engagement ring, as well as what each means for your relationship status moving forward.

Is a Promise Ring an Engagement Ring?

Engagement ring on a finger

The simple answer is no; promise rings aren’t engagement rings. While promise rings symbolize love or commitment, they don’t have the same meaning as engagement rings. A promise ring is given as a sign of commitment or love without expecting it to lead to marriage. It can be used by couples who want to take things slowly or those who don’t feel ready for marriage yet still want to show their partner that they care deeply for them.

Conversely, an engagement ring is typically worn by someone who has already been proposed to and accepted the proposal.

This type of jewelry symbolizes that there’s now an official commitment between two partners in terms of their future together.

However, it’s worth noting that there are no hard and fast rules. In the end, it’s up to the couple to decide what they want to call their ring and also what it means. For instance, these days, a promise ring can mean anything from “I’m sorry” to “I love you” to “I’ll always be there for you.”

So, if you’re curious about what a promise ring means for you and your loved one, it’s important to have a conversation and come up with a definition that works for both of you to avoid misunderstandings down the road.

What Is a Promise Ring? The Real Meaning and Purpose

In essence, promise rings (also known as purity rings) are a symbol of commitment. They may be given as a promise to be in a monogamous relationship or to take care of one another during difficult times. Sometimes, they’re also given as a constant reminder of a verbal promise between one person and another.

Promise rings with i will always love you

In most cases, the ring isn’t specifically about marriage but about a committed relationship that’s considered to be special. It may be given as a gift and sign of appreciation for all that the other partner (or even best friend) has done for the giver or as a symbol of love and loyalty.

A promise ring isn’t generally seen as an engagement ring, but it can sometimes be used in place of one. For example, if a couple isn’t quite ready to get married but wants to show their commitment, they may give each other promise rings.

Sometimes, people wear promise rings until they’re ready to get married and then switch to wearing an engagement ring. Other times, a couple will continue to wear their promise rings even after getting married, so there’s no standard practice.

Both promise rings and engagement rings started becoming popular during the Victorian era (mainly acrostic rings), although they were used for different purposes. Engagement rings were used as a promise of marriage, while promise rings were given as a way to celebrate and express commitment and love between people who weren’t married.

Simple silver promise ring

These days, there’s a growing trend for promise rings to be given as a pre-engagement ring. This means that it isn’t necessarily an indication that the couple is planning to get married soon, but it’s a sign of their commitment to one another. Many couples will also choose to have a matching set of promise rings (or pre-engagement rings) and use them as their wedding bands.

So, the meanings of a promise ring and engagement ring, or purity ring can vary depending on the couple. For some, it may be an indication that they’re going to get married sometime in the future and signals a lifetime commitment, while for others, it means something else entirely.

The Difference Between a Promise Ring and an Engagement Ring

There are key differences between a promise ring vs. engagement ring. Here are a few:

  • A promise ring isn’t always given in anticipation of marriage, while an engagement ring is always given with the intention of eventually getting married.
  • A promise ring often doesn’t have a diamond or any other larger stone in it, while an engagement ring usually does.
  • An engagement ring meaning is a permanent commitment between two people, while a promise ring may or may not be a permanent commitment.
  • While the giving of the perfect engagement ring usually involves bending down on one knee in a romantic dinner, the giving of a promise ring is usually more casual, like giving a gift.
Man putting an engament ring on a woman
  • A promise ring can simply mean that you’re committed to being together and being faithful to one another for the time being, while an engagement ring means that you’ve been proposed to and have accepted the marriage proposal.
  • If you get a promise ring, it doesn’t mean that the partner giving it to you is necessarily planning on proposing to you in the future.
  • The average cost of a promise ring – see women’s gold rings – may only be a fraction of the price of an engagement ring, but this doesn’t mean that it isn’t valuable. It’s just that they come at different price points since the latter is like a wedding ring (or even eternity rings) in most cases.
  • While an engagement ring signifies a proposal and symbolizes the beginning of a lifelong commitment, it doesn’t always lead to a successful marriage.

As you can see, there are many differences between a promise ring and an engagement ring. Yet, the most important would be the fact that an engagement ring is always given with the intent of getting married, while a promise ring doesn’t have to carry that connotation.

It’s up to the couple involved to decide what meaning a promise ring holds for their relationship, but it’s safe to say that it usually signifies a deeper commitment than just being together. In contrast, an actual engagement ring is a sign that two people are officially engaged and committed to each other for the long haul.

MAn holding a box with a ring


Does a Promise Ring Mean You’re Engaged?

No, a promise ring doesn’t automatically mean that you and your partner are engaged to be married. It does indicate a strong relationship and commitment between you, but it’s not the same as an engagement ring. So when someone gives you a promise ring, it doesn’t necessarily mean that they’re planning to propose.

On Which Finger Should I Wear My Promise Ring?

There’s no specific rule about which finger you should wear your promise ring on. Choose any finger you want, as long as it feels comfortable and looks good to you. Some people choose to wear their rings on the same finger as their engagement ring (ring finger on the left hand), but there’s no requirement to do so.

Can You Marry Someone With a Promise Ring?

Generally, a promise ring isn’t seen as an engagement ring, so it’s not always viewed as an acceptable symbol of marriage. It can be used as a replacement for an engagement ring if you want to continue wearing the same piece of jewelry, but most people may not see it as being equivalent. Yet, again, there are no rules – it depends on each couple.

What Does It Mean When You Wear Two Rings?

In most cases, wearing promise rings and engagement rings together doesn’t actually have a specific meaning. You can wear both your promise ring and your engagement ring simultaneously if you want to (one on the right hand and one on the left hand), or just one of them on its own. It’s up to you and how much importance you want to give each ring.

Do Promise Rings Look Different Than Engagement Rings?

Many promise rings or purity rings are similar to engagement rings, which is probably why people often get them confused. However, promise rings are typically simpler, while engagement rings or wedding rings have diamonds or gemstones.

Promise ring that makes a heart

The Bottom Line

So, promise ring vs. engagement ring – are they the same? In most cases, no – but a promise ring is a great way to celebrate your relationship and express your commitment and love for another individual.

Just remember that regardless of the promise ring meaning, you shouldn’t be afraid to ask questions about its symbolism and make your intentions clear. This will help you better understand your romantic relationship with your partner.

What matters most is that both people in the relationship are on the same page about what their rings mean and how important they are to them, regardless of what others outside the relationship think. So, showcase your rings with pride!

Leave a Comment