5 Best Places to Buy Diamond Earrings in 2023 Reviewed | What To Look For in a Prospective Gemstone Seller

Diamonds are the most valuable gemstones that you can find. They are one of the most well-known and sought-after gemstones in the world, and for a good reason: they’re incredibly beautiful. Diamonds come in a large variety of colors – white is not the only available option. While diamonds can be incredibly expensive (even cut glass can cost thousands of dollars), they’re often not too hard to come by. For one, the jewelry industry is always looking for diamonds to cut and polish into earrings or necklaces, or rings, so it makes sense that someone is looking to sell you these. Keep reading to know the best place to buy diamond earrings.

Top 3 Places to Buy Diamond Earrings

[Best Overall]

1. James Allen

James Allen jewelry and logo

  • Offers free ring sizing
  • Has a risk-free trial period
  • High-quality diamonds

[Best for the Money]

2. Blue Nile

Blue Nile jewelry and logo

  • Certificate of authenticity
  • High-quality products and design
  • An excellent return policy

[Best Customer Service]

3. Zales

Zales logo and collections

  • Special financing offers and discounts
  • Free shipping and returns
  • Various designs

Best Place to Buy Diamond Earrings- Buying Guide

Where should you buy your diamond earrings? The answer to that question largely depends on what you’re looking for and your budget. If you’re looking for the best possible quality, then here are a few factors to consider when choosing the best place to buy diamond studs and earrings:

The Store Should Have a Good Selection of Diamond Earrings 

When you go to a store to buy diamond earrings, you should be able to find a wide variety of styles and shapes. The store should have everything from diamond studs to hoops to dangle earrings. If the store doesn’t have a good selection, then it’s not the best place for you to buy diamond earrings.

There Should Be Qualified Jewelers Available to Help You 

When looking for diamond earrings, you’ll want to work with a qualified jeweler. The jeweler should help you find the perfect pair of earrings and answer any questions you may have about diamonds. If the store doesn’t have any qualified jewelers available, you might want to consider shopping elsewhere.

The Prices Should Be Reasonable 

One of the most important factors when choosing a store to buy diamond earrings is price. The store should offer reasonable prices for their earrings. The prices should not be too high. You don’t want to overspend when you’re buying diamond earrings, so the store must offer good prices. You should also be able to find a good deal on diamond earrings without having to compromise on quality.

A Good Return Policy

If you’re not happy with your purchase, you should be able to return the earrings without any problems. The store should have a good return policy in place so that you can get your money back if you’re not satisfied with the purchase.

The Store Should Be Reputable 

When you’re buying diamond earrings, you want to ensure that you’re dealing with a reputable store. The store should have a good reputation and be known for selling high-quality diamond earrings. You don’t want to deal with a store that sells low-quality diamond earrings or has a bad reputation.

Best Places to Buy Diamond Earrings: Reputable Stores Reviewed

1.[Best Overall] James Allen

As we concluded in our full James Allen review, it is one of the best places to buy diamond earrings because they offer free ring sizing in their store, custom-made appearance depending on your preference, and high-quality diamonds for every purchase. They also have an education course that can teach you more about diamonds, engagement rings, wedding bands, etc.

James Allen jewelry and logo

Their presence online is easy to access and has a user-friendly interface that you will appreciate. They also have an excellent team of customer service representatives who can answer all your questions and concerns professionally.

They offer free ring sizing for their customers, which is a very nice touch to the overall experience of buying from them. The visual search feature also lets you see what a certain diamond stud earring will look like from different angles.

Their online catalog is easy to browse through, and you can filter the results based on price, color, carat weight, shape, etc. They also have an advanced search function that allows you to find your diamond necklace or ring quickly and conveniently without spending too much time browsing for specific models.

3 engagement ring models by James Allen

You will have a 30-day risk-free trial period when buying from James Allen. You can also avail of free return shipping within the US if you are not happy with the product that you bought from them. The customer support team is on standby to answer all your questions and concerns to ensure that your queries get addressed promptly.

The Gemstone collection available gives you a wide range and variety of options to choose from. The Diamond stud earrings collection is also comprehensive and has different price points, so customers can find the diamond earrings they need without breaking the bank.

The real-time interactive diamond inspection feature adds a very nice touch as it allows you to see what the diamond stud earrings would look like if they were right in front of you.

In addition, their price alerts feature can tell you when there are any changes on their website so you can check and compare prices before your purchase.

Experience the diamond revolution with James Allen’s collection, available in top jewelry stores nationwide or on their website. You can also buy directly from them without paying any surcharges or fees.

James Allen diamond tennis bracelet

Visit their website or follow them on social media pages for the latest deals and offers available on their diamond stud earrings.


  • Offers free ring sizing
  • Has a risk-free trial period
  • Offers customizations and high-quality diamonds for every purchase
  • 30 day risk-free trial period


  • Does not have a physical store nearby for people who prefer in-person shopping experiences

2. [Best for the Money] Blue Nile

Bluenile.com is a good place to buy diamond earrings. They have a wide selection of earrings in all shapes, sizes, and prices. You can also find a variety of settings, including diamond studs, hoop earrings, and dangles. The online store started in 1999 and is based in Seattle, Washington.

BlueNile.com has a 100% satisfaction guarantee, so you can shop with confidence, knowing that if you’re not happy, you can return it for a full refund. Blue Nile also offers free shipping on all diamond earrings and makes searching for specific items or collections easy.

Blue Nile jewelry and logo

The diamond earrings at BlueNile.com come with a certificate of authenticity, so you can be sure that the diamonds are natural. The earrings are also insured against damage and loss, so you can rest assured that your purchase is protected. The site offers a wide variety of payment options, including PayPal, Visa, and Mastercard. Any loose diamond earrings could be sized at no additional cost if the item was purchased over 30 days ago.

BlueNile.com is a reliable place to purchase diamond earrings because they offer quality products and make returns painless.

In other words, BlueNile is a safe website to buy genuine diamonds that all come with a certificate of authenticity. You can also get them sized for free if you purchase earrings that are too big or small. The site has a wide variety of options for diamond earrings. They also have an excellent return policy if the earrings arrive damaged or you decide you don’t want them.

a model wearing Blue Nile jewelry

Additionally, the company has a wide variety of options for payment and shipping.

They also guarantee that their diamonds are 100% authentic. The online store is an excellent place to buy diamond earrings because they offer high-quality items while making returns painless. There is other jewelry like diamond rings, necklaces, bracelets, and watches. Their products are packaged with care and safety and insured against loss or damage during delivery.

The Blue Nile is an excellent website to find diamonds for sale. They provide information on the diamond earrings, including price prices, and make it easy for you to search for specific items or collections.

The variety of diamond earrings on the website is also great, with studs, hoops, and dangles available. You can also find a certificate of authenticity for each diamond to ensure that you’re getting what you’re paying for. If you have any sizing needs, Blue Nile will resize any loose diamonds free of charge if purchased over 30 days ago.

They offer educational articles on the website to answer any questions regarding diamonds. The education elaborates more about the properties of diamonds, including clarity, color, and carat weight. They also offer educational articles on diamond earring care and how to go about finding the perfect pair. The site also has a section with frequently asked questions to guide you through your shopping experience.

diamond jewelry by Blue Nile

The assortment of diamond earrings on the Blue Nile is fantastic. They are a perfect gift for any occasion, whether it is an anniversary, birthday, or to say “I love you.” The site is reliable because they offer quality products with a high-end appearance. Moreover, the diamond upgrade program at the Blue Nile allows you to trade in an old diamond and use the value to buy a higher quality, bigger stone.

They also have live help and educational articles to guide you through your shopping. To find the perfect diamond earrings, you can customize carat weight, clarity grade, color grade, and metal type personality. The conflict-free diamond earrings are also available at the online store.

The diamond price match guarantee is also available to the customers at the Blue Nile. The company allows you to trade in existing diamonds to buy a higher quality stone using the value.


  • Diamond earrings come with a certificate of authenticity
  • Guarantees 100% authenticity
  • High-quality products and design


  • Have to pay for the return shipment if you want to send the item back.

3. [Best Customer Service] Zales

Having been in business since 1924, Zales is an establishment with a lasting history of quality products and services. The store only has one location in the mall, making it convenient when shopping for diamond earrings. Zales is a well-known and reputable jeweler with an online presence and physical stores across the United States. They offer a wide selection of diamond earrings, including both solitaire and stud earrings, in a variety of styles and price ranges. The merchandise is of high quality, but the prices are affordable. Zales.com also offers free shipping on all orders and a 30-day return policy.

Zales logo and collections

When buying diamond stud earrings, it’s advisable to seek advice from a jeweler with expertise in diamonds. The Zales Diamond Expert is a special designation given to some of their staff members who have completed extensive diamond grading and style training. They are happy to provide consultations over the phone or through email.

Upon purchase, your earrings will be set by a jeweler employing sophisticated techniques that meet strict standards for security and quality. When you buy diamond earrings from Zales, you also receive the Zales Lifetime Diamond Commitment: If your stud diamonds ever need to be replaced due to loss, theft, or accidental damage, Zales will replace them with stones of equal quality and value free of charge. Its commitment to customer satisfaction is also evident through this lifetime diamond commitment policy which ensures that customers can upgrade their diamonds without any extra cost.

Rings from Zales store

Your choice of diamond will be laser-inscribed onto the studs before they are shipped out to you, so you can quickly identify your earrings if they are ever lost or stolen. If you make a purchase but decide to return it for any reason within 30 days of receiving it, Zales will provide free return shipping on their dime.

If the original diamond quality is not up to par with your standards upon delivery, they will gladly replace them for you at no extra charge.

Zales has affordable credit options for consumers and provides financing options with no down payment. With the Zales Credit Card, you will receive special financing offers and discounts that will help you maximize your savings on future purchases.

If you want to upgrade your diamond stud earrings to better quality, Zales will sell you loose diamonds at wholesale prices and provide free shipping on them as well. Do you need a stone replaced, a clasp repaired, or a rhodium re-dip?

Zales offers free repairs and services for the lifetime of your earrings.

If your studs ever need any repair after purchase, Zales offers jewelry services that include ring sizing for free or diamond re-mounting for a fee. They also provide warranty protection for an extra charge. For online purchases, you have the option to return your earrings by mail for a no-questions-asked refund.

Zales is a reliable and affordable source for diamond stud earrings with various style options, and their customer service is outstanding. With their Credit Card, you can enjoy special financing offers and discounts on future purchases.

various jewelry from Zales store

Apart from earrings, the store also offers various diamond jewelry options. There are diamond wedding rings, necklaces, bracelets, and pendants. The authenticity guarantees the diamonds are very lucrative for buyers since there are no extra costs involved. Free shipping policy is also attractive for online shoppers.

Online shopping offer by Zales

Zales has always been committed to giving back to local communities by supporting trendy annual fundraising events like Breast Cancer Awareness Month, when they provide special promotions and discounts.

All these reasons make Zales the go-to place for buying diamond stud earrings and other diamond jewelry. With a variety of style options, affordable prices, outstanding customer service, and commitment to giving back.

Overall, Zales is a reputable and affordable place to buy diamond earrings. With their emphasis on diamonds, customers are assured of quality.


  • Wide selection of diamond earrings
  • Lifetime diamond commitment
  • Free shipping and returns
  • Affordable credit options
  • Special financing offers and discounts


  • Some colored jewelry looks cheap

4. Jared

Jared offers holiday deals that you can take advantage of when purchasing diamond earrings. They offer discounts on jewelry using coupon codes and special promotions. The company offers holiday deals to entice customers to buy “the perfect gift” for their loved ones.

It’s because Jared Jewelry offers free ring sizing with every purchase, especially during the holidays. You can also purchase a personalized gift box. It is best to use coupon codes when buying diamond stud earrings. Let’s look at some of these promotions for the remainder of 2017.

Jared store logo

Jared Diamonds Holiday Deals for this December

Diamond stud earrings are among the most popular jewelry pieces people buy during the holiday season. To help you decide which ones to get, Jared offers discounts and deals at the most reasonable rates.

Jared runs their Black Friday and Cyber Monday promotions for diamond earrings every year. The company is known to offer the best prices for studs and diamonds and discounts on wedding rings. It’s an excellent way for you to buy your loved one a piece for less than $100 at Jared. To own diamond earrings at a very affordable price, visit Jared stores this December.

The virtual holiday gift guide promotion gives you a chance to win a Jared coupon. You can use this to buy diamond earrings during the holidays. The holiday contest for Jared customers lets you earn one entry per week when purchasing any diamond jewelry.

various items from Jared jewelry store jew

Jared also ensures that you can avail of their coupons and promo codes every time. Sign up for Jared’s email list to be updated on holiday offers and discounts this 2021. You can also follow them on Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram.

The Jared bridal earrings promotion lets you get more than 20% off your purchase. It’s a great way to save more for brides-to-be when getting diamond earrings for themselves or their bridal parties.

The holiday deals and discounts allow you to buy Jared’s best wedding rings and diamond stud earrings at an affordable price. You can get free ring sizing with every purchase, especially during the holidays. You can even have it personalized. You have 20% off on Jared diamond earrings this year with this promo. You can also get free ring sizing at Jared outlets.

The jewelry education from Jared is your gateway into the world of diamonds. After completing this course, you will know more about Jared’s products and services. You can even get a gift for enrolling in their school.

The customer services team is more than willing to answer your queries and concerns.

The Jared store services are built to help you find the perfect pieces of diamond jewelry. The Jared stores also have a personal diamond consultant who will assist you in finding your dream earrings. They offer repair services, too. Giving back to society is one of their primary goals for running a business.

rings on female fingers

Jared also offers free ring sizing with every purchase, especially during the holidays. The Jared Diamonds Holiday Deals for this December are certainly one of the best ways to make your loved ones happy this Christmas. If you need custom diamond earrings, you can check out their website for more information regarding the Jared jewelry sale and promotion.

Anniversary gift offer by Jared

There are several payment options that you can choose from when buying diamond earrings.

You can pay with your credit card, PayPal, or even through installments if you use any major credit cards accepted by Jared. It’s to help you fit your holiday budget this 2021.

To buy diamond stud earrings at a very affordable price, visit Jared stores this December. The Jared Black Friday and Cyber Monday deals can help you save more on your purchase of diamond earrings. Get up to 25% off for 2021 by visiting their store outlets. Jared’s have such a wide range of hypoallergenic diamond studs, even those with sensitive ears are catered for.

Perhaps you are looking for the best place to buy diamond engagement rings. The luxury royal collection is sure to catch your eye, and its classic design will entice any woman you want to spend the rest of your life with.


  • They offer the best diamond earrings
  • Has latest designs of diamond stud earrings
  • Free ring sizing at any Jared store outlet
  • Over 20% discount on wedding rings


  • It cannot be used to purchase products other than diamond jewelry

5. Kay

Online shopping is always more convenient than doing it in person. It’s true when shopping for diamond stud earrings on Kay. You can get more discounts on your purchase and avail of special deals and offers on their website.

The diamond education course taught by Kay Jewelers is meant to help you learn more about their collection of engagement rings, wedding bands, and earrings. Diamond stud earrings are available in different designs and styles. They also have personalized options that can be selected according to preference or liking. You can even choose the best type of metal for your earrings.

Kay Jewelers photo and logo

There are several payment options, and you can even use Kay points to give back to society or for your purchases. You have to turn in the required amount of Kays at their website, and they’ll be exchanged into a charitable donation that can help save a life from cancer. For holiday shoppers looking to buy diamond studs, Kay is one of the best places to do so.

Diamond stud earrings are available in different price ranges to suit your budget and needs. You can purchase a single pair or get multiple teams for yourself and another person. You can even avail of free ring sizing at any Kay store outlet for every purchase made.

Kay is one of the best places to buy diamond earrings because they give back to society differently. You can even participate in their non-profit organization that helps save lives worldwide by donating through their website.

The free ring sizing service is just one of the many added benefits you will enjoy when shopping with them. They also participate in various organizations that aim to save more lives and do some good for cancer survivors worldwide.

You can even volunteer your time or donate through Kay’s website.

What you learn from the jewelry education program will benefit you in your future purchases.

Personalized Valentine's pendants by Kay

The Kay Jewelry expert staff is friendly and well-trained, ensuring that you get the best service when shopping for their diamond jewelry collection. They will ensure that your transaction with them will be safe and secure. Their new visual search feature is also imposing, with its 3D rendering technology that can show you what your diamond stud earrings would look like from different angles.

Their engagement and fashion jewelry collection can be seen on their website. You can also avail of free ring sizing when visiting their malls nationwide or give back to society by donating through their website.

Atricles in Kay Shop

The products are easy to maintain since they are hypoallergenic. It’s an added advantage for people who need earrings for sensitive ears and those allergic to certain metals.

You can check their website or social media pages for the latest deals and offers available on their jewelry collection, as well as news and updates about events and other things that they may organize in the future.

You will find a great variety of silver and gold earrings in their catalog. They also offer complimentary ring sizing to tell the brand about your experience with them. Kay’s in-house customer care and services team is always ready to help its customers. If you need more information on Jared Diamonds Sale 2021, drop by their stores or give them a call.


  • Has a wide range of diamond stud earrings
  • Offers free ring sizing at any Kay store
  • You can learn more about diamonds with their education course
  • Has the latest technology for visual search


  • Operates only in the US

When to Avoid Buying Diamond Earrings From a Certain Seller Online

Online diamond sellers come in all shapes and sizes. Some are reputable and trustworthy, while others are not. Here are a few tips to help you avoid buying diamond earrings from a seller:

Odd Web Address

One way to avoid a bad seller is to check their website address. If it is something strange like “jewlerybestbuy7.com” or “bestsalej12.com”, there may be a higher chance of it being a shady diamond earrings dealer. Instead, look for web addresses that start with https://, which signifies a more reputable site.

Unprofessional Website Design

If the website design looks unprofessional, it’s likely that the seller is not reputable. A professional website will have high-quality graphics, be easy to navigate and would look trustworthy. If the website looks like it was made in a hurry or is filled with spelling mistakes, it’s best to avoid buying from that seller.

Low-Quality Images

When you’re looking at diamond earrings online, be sure to check the quality of the images. If they are blurry or pixelated, likely, the diamonds are not real. Reputable sellers will always use high-quality images to show off their products.

Unanswered Questions

If you have any questions about the diamond earrings, be sure to ask the seller before making a purchase. A reputable seller will be happy to answer any of your questions and provide all the information you need to make an informed decision.

Seller Uses Stock Photos

If the seller is using stock photos instead of images of their product, likely, they are not reputable. Reputable sellers will always use photos of their products to show potential buyers what they’re buying.

No Ratings or Reviews

If the seller has no ratings or reviews, likely, they are not reputable. A good way to determine a seller’s trustworthiness is to see how many ratings and reviews they have. A lack of ratings and reviews is often a sign that the seller is not trustworthy.


Which diamond is best for earrings?

Different diamond shapes are better suited for different pieces of jewelry. When you’re buying diamond earrings, your best bet is to choose brilliant round diamonds. These diamonds have the highest brilliance and sparkle. They look beautiful in almost any type of jewelry so they will make fabulous earrings.

Are Costco diamonds a good value?

It is possible to find good deals on diamonds at stores like Costco, but you should know about their diamond grading system before buying. The Costco Diamond Grading System will give you a good idea of how much that diamond’s quality is worth.

Are there other places to buy earrings besides jewelry stores?

There are other places besides jewelry stores where you can buy earrings. You can buy earrings online, at department stores, or specialty stores. It’s important to do your research before you purchase so that you can find the best possible deal on diamond earrings.

Where should I buy my diamond earrings?

Where you buy your diamond earrings will depend on several things, including what you’re looking for and your budget. It’s important to find a store that has good prices, with jewelers who can help you choose the perfect pair of earrings. You should also make sure that the store is reputable and has a good return policy in place.


When buying diamond earrings, it’s important to do your research and shop around. You should make a point of visiting several different stores and checking out their selection before you buy. You should also consider the store’s quality, price, and reputation when making your decision. If you do all of your research and take your time, it will be much easier to find the perfect diamond earrings.