Where Should I Buy a Diamond Ring? | Do NOT Make an Expensive Mistake!

We all love sparkly diamonds. Women want to be dazzled by diamond rings, and men want to make sure their ladies are showered with them. Where should I buy a diamond ring?

If you have decided it’s the right time to buy an engagement ring, but haven’t been sure where to start looking for it, then this is the right place to be.

Here we’ll discuss the best places to buy diamond jewelry, and what questions should be answered before making a purchase.

Key Takeaways

  • When buying a diamond ring, there are several options to consider. Local jewelry stores, private jewelers, online retailers, and the Diamond District are all popular choices.
  • Local stores offer the convenience of being able to see the ring in person and receive personalized service, but prices may be higher than other options.
  • Private jewelers offer a more customized experience and can often create custom designs, but prices may also be higher.
  • Online retailers offer a wider selection and often lower prices, but the buyer cannot see the ring in person before purchasing.
  • The Diamond District is a hub for diamond wholesalers and retailers, offering a wide selection at lower prices, but it is important to know the diamond engagement ring that you want to buy and choose a reputable seller.
  • Ultimately, it comes down to what is most important to the buyer; convenience, quality, customization, price, or selection.

Where Should I Buy a Diamond Ring?

Nowadays, it’s easy to find a diamond engagement ring that fits your budget and style. There are many options on the market, from department stores to online retailers.

A diamond ring up close

If you’re in the market for a diamond ring, consider these tips before you buy:

Shop Around

Don’t settle for the first engagement ring you see. Take your time and compare prices at several different jewelry stores or online retailers. You might be surprised to find that some stores offer better deals than others, even if they don’t have as much name recognition as other stores in your area.

Know What You Want

Know what you want before you start shopping around so that you don’t waste time looking at engagement rings that aren’t right for you or your partner. If there are certain qualities that are important to you (such as cut grade), make sure that they come up in your search results when shopping for an engagement ring online or in person at retail locations near you.

Don’t rush to order an engagement ring if it doesn’t feel right especially if it doesn’t fit within your budget.

An engagement ring

Local Stores

When it comes to buying a diamond ring, there are many options available. One of the most popular options is to purchase from a local jewelry store. Chain jewellers like James Allen or Blue Nile and others, tend to have higher prices than independent boutiques because they’re focused on corporate profits. Here are more reasons why you might want to do engagement ring shopping from a local store:

Personalized Service

When you buy from a local store, you’ll have the opportunity to talk one-on-one with a knowledgeable salesperson who can help you choose the perfect engagement ring with a special meaning. They can answer any questions you might have, provide advice on the best styles and cuts, and even help you find the right diamond size.

Quality Assurance

Local stores typically have strict quality standards, so you can be confident that you’re getting a high-quality diamond ring.

They often have diamonds that have been certified by reputable organizations such as the Gemological Institute of America (GIA), which provides assurance that the diamond is of high quality.

A diamond between tweezers


Shopping at a local store means you don’t have to wait for shipping or pay extra shipping costs. You can see the diamond engagement ring in person and take it home with you the same day.

Return Policy

If you change your mind or have any problems with the diamond jewelry, it is much easier to return or exchange it when you purchase from a local store.

Support Local Business

Buying engagement rings from a local store helps support the local economy and small businesses in your community.

Lots of diamond


Many local stores offer custom design services that allow you to design and buy your own engagement ring or alter existing designs to make your ring smaller, for example.

When buying engagement rings from a local store, it’s important to do your research. Look for a reputable store with a good reputation, and be sure to ask about the quality of the diamonds they carry. You can also check online reviews to see what other customers have said about their experiences.

Online Jewelry Store: Best Place to Buy Engagement Ring Online

One of the most popular ways to buy diamond engagement rings is through an online jewelry store. A reputable website will offer detailed information about its products and services, including descriptions of each piece, images, pricing, and payment options.

They should also offer customer reviews of their best engagement rings

so that you can get an idea of what others think before making a purchase.

Online shopping

Offers Convenience

Buying a diamond ring from an online diamond retailer has many benefits. One of the biggest advantages is convenience. Many online stores are open 24/7, so you can shop for a ring at any time, from anywhere.

This means you can browse through a wide selection of diamond rings without having to leave your home or take time off work.

Have A Wide Selection of Diamond Engagement Rings

Another benefit of buying a diamond ring from an online store is the ability to compare prices and styles. Online stores typically have a larger selection of diamond rings, fancy color diamonds, and fancy-shaped diamonds than brick-and-mortar stores, which allows you to compare prices and styles, like whether you want a halo or no halo engagement ring.

Additionally, many online jewelers offer detailed information about the diamonds they sell, including carat weight, cut, clarity, and color, so you can make an informed decision about your purchase.

On top of all that, you will get the most money for your diamond ring if you sell it online to one of the professional jewelry buyers.

Close up of an elegant engagement diamond ring on woman finger

Are Less Expensive

When you buy engagement rings online , it can be less expensive than buying from a brick-and-mortar store. Online stores often have lower overhead costs, which allows them to offer diamond rings at lower prices.

 In addition, many online stores offer free or discounted shipping, which can save you even more money.

Private Jewelers

These types of jewelers offer a more personalized shopping experience, which can be beneficial for those who are looking for a specific type of diamond or setting.

Additionally, private jewelers often have access to a wider variety of loose diamonds, which can allow for more custom and unique diamond rings.

Private Jewelers

Help to Buy an Engagement Ring

One advantage of going to a private jeweler is that they can help you navigate the process of selecting the perfect diamond for your ring.

They can provide guidance on the 4 Cs (carat, cut, color, and clarity) of diamonds, as well as help you understand the different types of engagement ring settings available. This can help ensure that you end up with an engagement ring that says the right things about you and truly represents your personal style and preferences.

How Many Carats Should a Diamond Ring Be?

The average total carat weight for an engagement ring in the U.S. hovers just over 1 carat, at 1.08 carats. The range of 1.0 to 1.9 carats is by far the most popular, but there are noticeable peaks at the 0.70 – 0.79 range, the 0.90 – 0.99 range and the 1.50 – 1.59 range. Some of the world’s largest diamond rings can weigh over 50 carats and are worth millions of dollars, though.

Diamond Cut Types

Put simply, cut is responsible for the quality of a diamond’s sparkle. If a diamond is cut poorly, it will appear dull even if it has a high color and clarity grade. If a diamond is cut well, it will reflect and refract light for maximum brightness and sparkle. Best diamond shapes and cuts include round, oval, cushion, princess, pear, emerald, marquise, asscher, radiant, and heart shaped diamonds.

What Colour Should Engagement Rings Be?

When choosing the right precious metal color for your engagement ring the most important thing is to pay attention to the tone of your skin. Your skin will either be light, medium or dark. If you have a warm skin tone, yellow gold and coppery colours will complement your complexion and look beautiful. Those with cool skin tones will benefit from white metals such as silver, platinum or white gold.

However, gold rings, for both men and women, remain the most favoured precious metals for settings, followed by platinum.

Which Diamond Clarity is Best?

The highest clarity for a diamond ring is Flawless (F). Flawless diamonds have no inclusions or blemishes visible under 10X magnification when examined by a qualified diamond grader.

Provide Custom-Made Diamond Ring

Another reason for shopping for an engagement ring from a private jeweler is that they may be able to provide a custom-made engagement ring. This means that you can work with the jeweler to create fine jewelry that is tailored to your specific needs.

Diamond District

The Diamond District is a well-known destination for purchasing diamond rings. Located in New York City and other places around the world, the Diamond District is home to a large concentration of diamond engagement ring retailers and jewelers. It is a popular place for those looking for a wide selection of diamonds at competitive prices.

Have a Wide Selection of Diamond Rings

One of the advantages of buying a diamond ring in the Diamond District is the ability to see and compare a large number of diamonds in person. This can be especially helpful for those who are not well-versed in the intricacies of diamond grading and want to make sure they are getting the best value for their money.

Additionally, many of the merchants in the Diamond District are wholesale diamond dealers, which can also help to keep prices competitive.

A lot of diamond rings

Buying Engagement Ring Online vs In Store

However, before you get down on one knee, you face a crucial decision: where should I buy an engagement ring? With the rise of e-commerce, the traditional in-store experience now competes with the convenience and accessibility of online shopping. Let’s explore the pros and cons of each option, so you can make an informed choice that suits your needs and preferences.

Online Shopping: The Modern Convenience

Online Shopping: The Modern Convenience


  1. Vast Selection: One of the significant advantages of buying an engagement ring online is the vast array of options available at your fingertips. Numerous online jewelers offer extensive collections, showcasing various styles, cuts, and gemstones. You can easily find the perfect ring that matches your partner’s personality and preferences.
  2. Price Comparison: Online shopping allows you to compare prices across multiple websites swiftly. This transparency empowers you to make an informed decision and potentially find a better deal within your budget.
  3. Convenience: Shopping for an engagement ring from the comfort of your own home is undeniably convenient. There’s no need to travel from store to store or adhere to specific business hours. You can browse and make a purchase at any time that suits you.
  4. Reviews and Testimonials: Reputable online jewelers often provide customer reviews and testimonials, giving you insights into the quality of their products and customer service. This valuable feedback can boost your confidence in the retailer and the ring you are purchasing.


  1. Lack of Physical Inspection: Not being able to see and touch the ring in person is a significant drawback of online shopping. While high-resolution images and detailed descriptions help, some may feel more comfortable examining the ring up close before making such an important purchase.
  2. Sizing Uncertainty: Obtaining the correct ring size can be tricky when shopping online. While many jewellers offer sizing tools and guidelines, there’s still a chance of getting it wrong, like making your engagement ring tighter than it should be, which can lead to potential resizing inconveniences.

In-Store Shopping: The Traditional Experience

In-Store Shopping: The Traditional Experience


  1. Personalized Experience: Shopping for an engagement ring in-store provides you with personalized attention from experienced sales representatives. They can guide you through the selection process, answer your questions, and help you find the ideal ring based on your partner’s preferences.
  2. Physical Inspection: Trying on rings in person allows you to see how they look on your hand and examine their craftsmanship and quality firsthand. This hands-on experience can be reassuring and help you make a confident decision.
  3. Immediate Gratification: Once you find the perfect ring, you can take it home immediately, without having to wait for shipping or deal with potential delivery delays.


  1. Limited Selection: Unlike online shopping, brick-and-mortar stores may have a more limited selection of engagement rings. This constraint could make it challenging to find the exact style or design you’re envisioning.
  2. Potentially Higher Prices: In-store retailers generally have higher overhead costs, which might be reflected in their pricing. You could end up paying more for a similar ring compared to an online counterpart.
  3. Pressure to Buy: Some buyers may feel pressured by the in-store environment to make a quick decision, especially if the sales representatives are eager to close a sale.

Overall, the choice to buy an engagement ring online or in-store depends on your preferences, budget, and comfort level. Consider factors like convenience, physical inspection, and the experience you desire. Regardless of your decision, the ring’s sentimental value as a symbol of love and commitment remains priceless, no matter where you purchase it.

How Much Does a Custom Made Engagement Ring Cost?

The cost of making an engagement ring can vary based on factors like materials, gemstone choice, and design complexity. On average, most couples spend between $3,000 and $10,000, or even more on custom-made engagement rings. However, prices can differ significantly. Consider personal preferences and work with a trusted jeweler to create a cherished symbol of love and commitment.

How Expensive Should an Engagement Ring Be?

Determining the cost of an engagement ring can be a personal and subjective decision. While a one-carat ring averages around $5,500, many couples spend more, with some even exceeding $10,000. However, it’s crucial to find a budget that aligns with your financial situation and your partner’s preferences.

FAQs: Best Place to Buy Diamond Ring

Should I Buy an Engagement Ring Online?

Yes, you can buy an engagement ring online, but the choice is ultimately yours. Many people find online shopping convenient as it allows for easy price and review comparisons across different stores. However, it’s a personal preference. Some local stores may offer great deals, while others may have unique, high-quality rings.

Is It Better to Buy Engagement Rings Online?

The answer varies from person to person. While some may prefer in-store purchases due to quality checks, others find online options more affordable. It’s worth exploring both avenues. If you like traditional jewelry stores but want online prices, discuss it with the jeweler; you might strike a deal.

Is It Cheaper to Buy an Engagement Ring Online or In Store?

Engagement rings tend to be more budget-friendly in-store. The primary reason is overhead costs. Physical retail stores have expenses like rent, staffing, and store maintenance, which can impact prices. In contrast, online retailers often offer competitive prices due to lower overhead.

Where Is the Best Place to Buy Diamonds?

The best place to buy diamonds depends on what is most important to the buyer. For convenience, online stores may be the best option. For quality and customization, private jewellers may be the best choice. For the price, online retailers or the Diamond District may offer the best deals. Ultimately, it is important to research and compare options to find the best place to buy diamonds that suit your needs and preferences. It is also important to ensure that the diamond is certified by a reputable organization such as GIA or AGS.

How Much Does a Decent Diamond Ring Cost?

The cost of a diamond ring can vary widely depending on factors such as the quality of the diamond, the type of setting, the jewelry designer, or the brand. A decent diamond ring can cost anywhere from $1,000 to $10,000, with the average cost being around $4,000. However, it’s also possible to find a diamond ring for less than $1,000 or much more than $10,000 depending on the specific ring and the buyer’s budget.

Which Brand of Diamond Is the Best?

There is no one “best” brand of diamonds as the quality and value of a diamond can vary greatly depending on factors such as cut, clarity, carat weight, and color. However, some reputable diamond brands include Tiffany & Co., Cartier, Harry Winston, and De Beers. It is important to do research and consult with a trusted jeweler to find a diamond that meets your specific needs and preferences.

diamond rings by james allen and blue nile

Final Thoughts on Where Should I Buy Diamond Ring

To sum up, purchasing a diamond ring can be an overwhelming experience, but it doesn’t have to be. By considering your options and doing some research, you can make a confident and informed decision about where to buy your diamond ring.

Whether you choose a local jewelry store, a private jeweler, or an online retailer, make sure to ask the right questions and fully understand the quality and value of the diamond you’re purchasing. Remember, a diamond ring is a significant investment, so take your time and choose wisely to avoid making an expensive mistake.

Leave a Comment